best tracker Skip to main content

Welcome to our comprehensive audiobook review of “A Higher Loyalty” by James Comey. As one of the most highly anticipated audiobooks of recent years, “A Higher Loyalty” provides listeners with fascinating insights into the mind of the former FBI Director.

In this review, we will explore the audiobook’s key themes, provide an overview of the narration and format, and analyze its impact on public perception. Join us as we delve deep into this thought-provoking memoir that discusses loyalty, leadership, ethics, and the inner workings of the FBI.

About the Author – James Comey

James Comey is a notable author and former FBI director who has been in the public eye for several decades. He served as FBI director under President Barack Obama and President Donald Trump until his dismissal in May 2017. Comey’s extensive background in law enforcement and government makes him a compelling figure, offering unique insights into the inner workings of the FBI and the highest levels of government.

During his tenure as FBI director, Comey oversaw several high-profile investigations, including the probe into Hillary Clinton’s emails and the allegations of Russian interference in the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election. Comey’s experiences in these investigations, as well as his interactions with prominent political figures, have contributed to his perspective on leadership, ethics, and public service, which are themes explored in his memoir “A Higher Loyalty.”

Comey’s background in law and government service began when he graduated from the University of Chicago Law School in 1985. He worked as a law clerk for U.S. District Judge John M. Walker Jr. before joining the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York, where he worked for six years. In 1996, Comey became the managing assistant U.S. attorney in charge of the Richmond Division of the Office of the U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia. He then moved on to serve as U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, and later, as the deputy attorney general under President George W. Bush.

Comey’s position as the FBI director made him one of the most controversial figures in U.S. politics during his tenure. His role in the 2016 election and decision to publicly comment on the Clinton email investigation caused significant public outcry and led to questions about his impartiality and judgment. Nevertheless, Comey’s memoir has received widespread attention and praise, offering unique insights into his experiences and perspectives on leadership, ethics, and public service.

Overview of “A Higher Loyalty”

James Comey’s “A Higher Loyalty” is a thought-provoking memoir that chronicles his experiences, both personal and professional. The book covers his tenure as the FBI director and the events leading up to his controversial dismissal by President Trump. Throughout the memoir, Comey emphasizes the importance of ethical leadership, accountability, and truthfulness.

The central themes of “A Higher Loyalty” include integrity, loyalty, and the rule of law. Comey shares his reflections on the major events he encountered during his career, bringing a unique perspective to the inner workings of the FBI and the Justice Department. From the investigation of Hillary Clinton’s emails to the Russian interference in the 2016 election, Comey provides a detailed account of his actions and motivations.

The structure of the memoir follows a linear timeline, beginning with Comey’s early career as a prosecutor in the U.S. Attorney’s office to his rise in the FBI under President Obama. Along the way, Comey provides personal anecdotes that offer insight into his character and motivations.

The Plot

“A Higher Loyalty” is not a typical memoir in that it delves into the most sensitive and controversial moments of Comey’s career in the FBI. The book follows a narrative arc that starts with Comey’s appointment as the Director of the FBI and traces the events leading up to his firing by President Trump.

Throughout the book, Comey provides commentary on his interactions with President Trump, discussing conversations that he interpreted as unethical and designed to subvert the independence of the FBI. Comey also shares his perspective on the investigations into Russian interference in the 2016 election and the subsequent firing of FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe.

Overall, “A Higher Loyalty” is a captivating memoir that offers readers unique insights into the most significant events of Comey’s career and motivations behind his actions. The book’s focus on ethical leadership and accountability makes it an essential read for anyone interested in the intricacies of the justice system and the role of the FBI in American politics.

Audiobook Format and Narration

When it comes to the audiobook format of “A Higher Loyalty,” listeners are treated to a polished production that enhances Comey’s already-compelling narrative. The audiobook is narrated by the author himself, making it an authentic and engaging listen.

Comey’s narration style is clear, concise, and delivered with the right tone for each chapter, whether he’s narrating a serious testimony or sharing personal anecdotes. In addition, the sound quality is excellent, making it a seamless and immersive listening experience.

Overall, the audiobook format of “A Higher Loyalty” receives high marks for its professional production quality and Comey’s engaging narration style, making it a worthwhile listen for anyone interested in politics or current events.

Key Themes Explored

“A Higher Loyalty” covers a range of key themes that are vital to understanding James Comey’s memoir. Throughout the audiobook, Comey reflects on his career and experiences, offering unique insights into various topical issues.


One of the primary themes in “A Higher Loyalty” is the concept of loyalty and its impact on individuals and organizations. Comey reflects on his own experiences with loyalty at the FBI and in his personal life, highlighting its complexities and tensions.


Comey also examines the concept of leadership in “A Higher Loyalty.” He offers his perspective on what it means to be an effective leader, the importance of transparency and accountability, and the challenges of leading during challenging times.

Ethics and Integrity

Throughout the audiobook, Comey discusses the importance of ethics and integrity, particularly in public service. He draws on personal experiences to illustrate how difficult it can be to maintain one’s integrity, particularly when faced with challenging ethical dilemmas.

The Workings of the FBI

“A Higher Loyalty” also offers a fascinating glimpse into the inner workings of the FBI. Comey discusses topics such as investigations, partnerships with other agencies, and the day-to-day operations of the Bureau. This provides the listener with a rare and valuable insight into one of America’s most prominent law enforcement agencies.

Personal Anecdotes and Revelations

James Comey’s memoir, “A Higher Loyalty,” offers a candid account of his experiences during his tenure as FBI Director. The book’s most significant draw is Comey’s personal anecdotes and revelations, which provide readers with a unique look into his life and career.

One of the most intriguing stories in the book is when Comey wrote about the time he was held captive by a serial rapist while he was a student at college. He reveals how the incident shaped his life and influenced his views on crime and punishment.

Another fascinating anecdote is when Comey talks about his role in the investigation of Hillary Clinton’s email scandal. He shares his thought process, as well as the obstacles he faced during the investigation, giving readers an inside look at the workings of the FBI during that time.

“I have had the fortune of being in the Oval Office many, many times in my career, with Presidents of the United States, but I will never forget the first time I was in. And it was to say goodbye to President Obama.”

Additionally, Comey shares his interactions with high-profile individuals, including former President Barack Obama and President Donald Trump. He discusses his experiences and impressions of them, providing readers with an insight into their personalities.

Overall, Comey’s personal anecdotes and revelations provide readers with a deeper understanding of his perspectives and experiences, making “A Higher Loyalty” an engaging and thought-provoking read.

Impact and Controversies

The release of “A Higher Loyalty” had a significant impact on the public’s perception of James Comey and sparked intense interest in the media and general public. Despite the positive reception of the book in some quarters, it also generated a fair share of controversies.

One of the most significant controversies surrounding the book was Comey’s decision-making processes during the 2016 U.S. presidential election. In the memoir, Comey recounts his experiences as the FBI director and his interactions with high-profile individuals, including his handling of the investigation into Hillary Clinton’s use of a private email server. The revelations made in the book led to criticism and scrutiny from politicians and the media, with many accusing Comey of influencing the election outcome.


The controversy around the book shed light on the public’s concern with the ethics and transparency of government institutions. Despite the backlash, “A Higher Loyalty” prompted a much-needed debate on loyalty, leadership, and ethical decision-making.

Relevance in Today’s Political Landscape

James Comey’s “A Higher Loyalty” is a memoir that has gained political relevance in the current events of the United States. In light of recent political controversies, Comey’s candid account of his experiences as FBI Director has implications that merit discussion.

The book has contributed to ongoing debates on loyalty, morality, and ethics in leadership. Comey offers insights on the kind of leadership needed in government agencies, specifically the FBI. His ideas on principles, honesty, and transparency are relevant, considering the risks of ethical compromises in today’s political climate.

“It matters that the President is not committed to the truth,” writes Comey in Chapter 9 of the memoir, alluding to President Trump.

Furthermore, the book deals with issues related to Russia’s involvement in the 2016 US Presidential elections. With the ongoing investigations into election meddling, Comey’s account of interactions with President Trump and the FBI’s independent investigation bears political relevance and raises implications for the country’s political future.

Overview Table: Political Implications of “A Higher Loyalty”

Topic Implications
Accountability in Government Agencies Comey highlights the need for transparency and honor in leadership roles in government agencies, calling for stricter accountability at the federal level.
Ethics and Morality in Politics “A Higher Loyalty” emphasizes the importance of ethics and moral values, inspiring readers to question the state of political morality in the country’s leadership.
Relationships with Foreign Powers Comey’s account of interactions with the Russian government leads to broader implications for US-Russian relations and raises questions about the country’s diplomatic ties.

Critical Reception

James Comey’s “A Higher Loyalty” has received widespread critical acclaim since its publication in 2018.

Many reviewers praised Comey’s writing style, noting his ability to craft a compelling and engaging memoir despite the complexity of the subject matter.

Additionally, the book’s frank portrayal of Comey’s controversial interactions with President Donald Trump generated significant public interest.

Reviews and Accolades

The audiobook has received positive reviews from a variety of prominent publications.

Publication Rating Review Excerpt
The New York Times Positive “A lucid and captivating account of what led up to the 2016 election, Russian interference and the investigation into Hillary Clinton’s private email server.”
The Guardian Positive “A Higher Loyalty is the first big memoir by a key player in the alarming melodrama that is the Trump administration…. [Comey’s] book fleshes out the testimony he gave before the Senate Intelligence Committee in June 2017 with considerable emotional detail.”
Publishers Weekly Positive “Comey, former FBI director, uses anecdotes and lessons from his storied career in law enforcement to urge Americans to stand up for the values they hold dear.”


Despite the largely positive critical reception, Comey’s memoir has not been without its detractors.

Some critics took issue with the author’s portrayal of his own actions, arguing that Comey’s decision-making processes were inconsistent and self-serving.

“… there are instances where Comey uses his memoir to excuse controversial decisions or settle scores.”

Others felt that “A Higher Loyalty” was overly focused on Comey’s own experiences and failed to provide a broader perspective on important political issues.

“… the book’s fixation on Comey’s personal experiences may have come at the expense of deeper analysis of key political themes.”

Comparisons to Other Political Memoirs

While “A Higher Loyalty” is a compelling and insightful political memoir, it is not the only one of its kind. There are several other notable political memoirs that readers may want to compare it to. Here are some of the most similar books:

Book Title Author Similarities to “A Higher Loyalty”
Decision Points George W. Bush Both books share insights into the leadership decisions made by high-ranking government officials.
The Truths We Hold Kamala Harris Both books cover the author’s experiences in law enforcement and politics, providing an insider’s perspective into these arenas.
What Happened Hillary Clinton Both books address controversial issues within American politics, offering the author’s perspective on these events.

These books share some similarities, but each has its unique aspects that set it apart from “A Higher Loyalty.” While “Decision Points” offers insights into the decision-making processes of another former US President, “The Truths We Hold” gives readers a firsthand account of the experiences of a high-profile politician of underrepresented groups in US politics. Meanwhile, “What Happened” explores the aftermath of a political campaign in great detail. Overall, each book provides a unique perspective on US politics and is worth reading in its own right.

Impact on Public Perception

James Comey’s memoir, “A Higher Loyalty,” captured the attention of a wide audience and undoubtedly had an impact on public perception. Through his personal anecdotes and revelations, Comey sheds light on some of the most controversial events of recent times, including the 2016 presidential election and his interactions with President Trump.

Positive Influence Negative Influence
A Higher Loyalty reinforced Comey’s public image as a principled and ethical leader, inspiring admiration and respect from individuals across the political spectrum. Conversely, Comey’s actions and decisions, as revealed in the book, generated criticism and skepticism from those who disagreed with his methods or motivations.
The memoir also influenced the public’s perception and understanding of the FBI, its role in government, and the principles that guide its work. On the other hand, some readers and critics claimed that the book contributed to a further erosion of public trust in political institutions and leaders, especially in a time of growing polarization and distrust.

“Comey’s memoir humanizes the FBI and serves to remind people of the critical role that the FBI plays in safeguarding our democracy,” said Senator Mark Warner.

“James Comey is a liar and a leaker and his misconduct led to the establishment of the Mueller investigation,” tweeted President Trump.

Overall, the impact of “A Higher Loyalty” on public perception is complex and multifaceted, reflecting the divisive nature of the events and issues it covers.

Lessons and Takeaways

“A Higher Loyalty” offers valuable lessons and takeaways that go beyond the author’s personal experiences. One of the key takeaways from Comey’s memoir is the importance of standing up for what is right, even when it is not easy or popular. Comey’s actions in various high-stakes situations highlight the significance of making ethical decisions, especially in positions of power.

Another lesson from “A Higher Loyalty” is the importance of values such as respect, honesty, and integrity in organizational cultures. Comey’s account of his time at the FBI emphasizes the importance of developing cultures that prioritize ethical and responsible behavior, which can help build trust between institutions and the public they serve.

Comey’s discussions on the impacts of his actions, personal and public, reiterate the importance of taking responsibility and being accountable for our choices. Whether in our personal or professional lives, acknowledging our mistakes and learning from them is necessary for growth, development, and building credibility.

“Ethical leadership is not about being easy or soft. It’s not about being warm and fuzzy. It’s about making hard, sometimes uncomfortable, choices.” – James Comey, “A Higher Loyalty”


After a comprehensive analysis of “A Higher Loyalty” by James Comey, it is clear that this audiobook offers a unique insight into the author’s experiences, values, and beliefs. The combination of Comey’s writing style and the narration by the voice actor make for an engaging listening experience.

The key themes explored in the audiobook, including loyalty, leadership, and ethics, are highly relevant to the contemporary political landscape, and the personal anecdotes and revelations shared by Comey provide valuable insights into the workings of the FBI.

Despite the controversies surrounding the book and its author, “A Higher Loyalty” has received widespread critical acclaim and is a must-listen for anyone interested in understanding the complex issues faced by law enforcement agencies and the ethical dilemmas that arise from these challenges.

In conclusion, we highly recommend “A Higher Loyalty” as a thought-provoking and informative audiobook that offers valuable lessons and takeaways for listeners from all walks of life.

Leave a Reply