best tracker Skip to main content

If you are looking for an enthralling audiobook to add to your must-read list, then look no further than “One of Us Is Next” by Karen M. McManus.

Following on from the success of her debut novel “One of Us Is Lying,” McManus delivers a gripping sequel that will have you hooked from start to finish. In this audiobook review, we’ll dive into the details of this thrilling tale and discover if it lives up to its predecessor.

Key Takeaways:

  • Karen M. McManus delivers another compelling thriller filled with twists and turns.
  • The audiobook version brings the story to life, with excellent narration and production quality.
  • “One of Us Is Next” stands out as an excellent sequel, with engaging characters and a captivating plot.
  • The book touches on thought-provoking themes and provides social commentary on relevant issues.
  • Readers and critics alike have praised “One of Us Is Next” for its exciting storyline and skilled writing.

Introduction to “One of Us Is Next”

Welcome to the world of Karen M. McManus’s “One of Us Is Next,” a gripping sequel to the bestselling novel “One of Us Is Lying.” In this thrilling story, McManus takes readers back to Bayview High School, where a new deadly game of Truth or Dare emerges. The stakes are high, and the consequences are deadly.

One of Us Is Next was published on January 7, 2020, and since then has captivated readers with its suspenseful plot, intricate characters, and relatable themes. The book has been praised for its ability to keep readers guessing until the very end, and for its compelling exploration of friendship, grief, and identity.

In the next sections, we’ll explore the world of One of Us Is Next and discuss the key aspects that make this novel a must-read.

The Author – Karen M. McManus

Before we delve into the plot and characters of One of Us Is Next, let’s first look at the author, Karen M. McManus. McManus is an American author who was born and raised in Massachusetts. She has a degree in English from the College of the Holy Cross and a Master’s degree in Journalism from Northeastern University.

McManus made her debut as an author in 2017 with the release of One of Us Is Lying, which was an instant New York Times bestseller. Since then, she has written several other books, including Two Can Keep a Secret and The Cousins.

Plot Overview

Get ready for an enthralling ride through the pages of “One of Us Is Next” as we uncover the fascinating plot of this captivating sequel. The story picks up where its predecessor, “One of Us Is Lying” left off, and takes us back to the fictional Bayview High School.

The plot follows the mysterious game of “Truth or Dare,” which gradually unfolds into a sinister and deadly scheme orchestrated by an unknown assailant. Amidst the escalating tension and fear, a group of students from Bayview High must band together to uncover the truth behind the horrifying game and put an end to the bloodshed before it’s too late.

The author, Karen M. McManus, masterfully weaves a tale of suspense, intrigue, and murder that will keep you on the edge of your seat until the very end. With its twists, turns, and unpredictable finale, “One of Us Is Next” is a must-read for anyone who loves thrillers and mysteries.

Key Events

Event Description
“Truth or Dare” Game A mysterious game of “Truth or Dare” starts circulating among Bayview High School students, but it soon turns into a life-and-death situation when secrets are exposed, and students start getting hurt.
Copycat Killer As the game continues, a copycat killer emerges, and the death toll rises. The students must race against time to expose the killer’s identity and stop them before more lives are lost.
The Final Reveal Without giving away too many spoilers, the final reveal in “One of Us Is Next” is shocking and unpredictable, leaving readers with a sense of satisfaction and closure.

Get ready to be hooked by the riveting plot of “One of Us Is Next.” With its intriguing premise, well-crafted characters, and suspenseful twists, this book is a must-read for fans of the thriller genre.

Character Analysis

Karen M. McManus creates a cast of dynamic characters that keep readers engaged throughout “One of Us Is Next.” Let’s analyze the key players and how they contribute to the story.

The Protagonists

Character Name Background Personality Motivation
Nate Comes from a wealthy family Charming, witty, guarded To protect his family and friends
Bronwyn A top student with high expectations Responsible, driven, idealistic To solve the mystery and restore order
Maeve An outsider with a troubled past Cynical, sarcastic, resourceful To prove herself and find justice for a loved one

These three protagonists have distinct personalities and backgrounds that add depth to the story. Each character has their own motivations and secrets that propel the plot forward and keep readers guessing.

The Antagonists

Character Name Background Personality Motivation
Simon’s Legacy A mysterious entity N/A To continue Simon’s game and seek revenge
Brandon Fitzsimmons A popular athlete Arrogant, entitled, jealous To prove his superiority and gain power
Hattie A follower of Simon’s cult Naive, impressionable, desperate To belong and find purpose

The antagonists in “One of Us Is Next” are equally intriguing, with motivations that are just as complex as the protagonists. The mystery surrounding Simon’s Legacy and their identity adds an element of suspense to the story, keeping readers engaged until the end.

Writing Style and Narrative

Karen M. McManus’s writing style in “One of Us Is Next” is enthralling, with the narrative seamlessly weaving together several compelling storylines that keep readers guessing until the very end. The author masterfully creates a sense of unease and suspense that permeates the audiobook, making for an intense and exciting listening experience.

In crafting the narrative, McManus employs various techniques, such as building up the tension slowly before delivering breathtaking and unexpected twists that leave listeners stunned. The use of multiple perspectives also adds depth to the story, allowing readers to understand the motives and feelings of different characters and their relationships with one another.

Overall, McManus displays remarkable skill in maintaining a steady pace, gradually ratcheting up the tension and keeping readers hooked until the satisfying conclusion. Her writing style creates a vivid and immersive world that captures the imagination of listeners and immerses them in the story’s intricate web of intrigue and suspense.

Pros Cons
The author creates suspense and maintains tension throughout the audiobook Some listeners may find the multiple perspectives confusing at times
The use of unexpected plot twists keeps readers engaged and hooked Occasional slow pacing may drag the story at times
The writing style creates a rich and immersive world that captures the imagination of the reader Some plot points may feel contrived or unrealistic

Audiobook Production

Creating a successful audiobook adaptation relies on a combination of factors, including the narrator’s performance, overall audio quality, and how well the story translates into this medium. In the case of “One of Us Is Next,” these elements come together to deliver a captivating listening experience.

Therese Plummer, the narrator of “One of Us Is Next,” brings a dynamic and nuanced performance to the audiobook. Her voice is clear, distinct, and effectively conveys the individual personalities of the characters. Plummer’s pacing matches the tense and suspenseful nature of the story, keeping listeners engaged from start to finish.

The audio quality of “One of Us Is Next” is excellent, with a crisp and clean recording. The sound effects, such as background music and special effects, are minimal but well-placed, adding to the overall atmosphere without being distracting or overwhelming.

The story itself translates seamlessly into audiobook format, with the narrator’s delivery effectively capturing the tension and intrigue of the plot. The pacing and tone are consistent throughout, creating a smooth and enjoyable listening experience.

Key Takeaways

  • Therese Plummer’s performance as the narrator of “One of Us Is Next” is superb, effectively conveying the personalities of the characters and matching the tone of the story.
  • The audio quality of the audiobook is excellent, with minimal but well-placed sound effects.
  • “One of Us Is Next” translates well into audiobook format, creating a smooth and enjoyable listening experience for fans of the book.

Pacing and Suspense

“One of Us Is Next” has a well-crafted and gripping plot that keeps readers on edge from start to finish. McManus balances the pacing masterfully, slowly building up the tension and revealing clues at a steady pace. As the book progresses, the sense of suspense intensifies, making it difficult to put the book down.

With short chapters, the story moves along at a quick pace, making it an ideal read for those who crave an exciting thriller. The author’s ability to maintain the momentum and keep readers engaged is commendable, which makes the book a page-turner.

The audiobook version of “One of Us Is Next” does an excellent job of capturing the pacing and suspense of the book. The narrator’s voice and tone add to the tension, creating a thrilling listening experience. The sound effects and music amplify the atmosphere, making it a truly immersive experience.

Balance of Pacing and Suspense

The balance between the pacing and suspense is critical in a thriller novel such as “One of Us Is Next.” McManus succeeds in providing the perfect mix, keeping readers engaged without overwhelming them. She allows readers to experience just enough suspense and anticipation to make the payoff satisfying and effective.

Pros Cons
  • Well-balanced pacing that keeps the story moving
  • Slowly ramps up the suspense and reveals clues at a steady pace
  • Short chapters make it a quick, thrilling read
  • Some readers may find the plot twists predictable
  • Characters can feel underdeveloped at times
  • The pace may be too slow for readers who prefer action-packed thrillers

Themes and Messages

One of the standout features of “One of Us Is Next” is the social commentary and moral dilemmas presented throughout the story. Karen M. McManus masterfully weaves important themes into the narrative, elevating the novel beyond a simple thriller.

At its core, “One of Us Is Next” is a commentary on the pervasive and damaging effects of bullying. The book explores the power dynamics at play in high school social hierarchies and how they can fuel toxic behavior. The themes of ostracism, exclusion, and peer pressure are portrayed with nuance and sensitivity, highlighting the emotional toll they can take on both the victims and perpetrators. The book challenges readers to examine their own attitudes towards bullying and to consider ways in which they can foster kindness and inclusion.

The novel also touches on the theme of identity, particularly as it relates to sexuality and gender. Through the character of Maeve, McManus portrays the complexities of navigating one’s personal identity, especially in the face of the expectations and judgments of others. The book encourages readers to embrace their true selves and to reject societal norms that constrain and limit individual expression.

Furthermore, “One of Us Is Next” explores the theme of justice and the importance of accountability. The book poses difficult questions about the nature of revenge and whether it can ever truly bring closure or healing. The moral dilemmas presented in the book will leave readers contemplating the nature of justice and the power dynamics within our legal system.

In short, “One of Us Is Next” is a thought-provoking novel that not only entertains but also challenges readers to reflect on their own values and beliefs. McManus artfully combines important themes with a gripping plot, making for an audiobook that is both engaging and inspiring.

Comparison to “One of Us Is Lying”

After the huge success of “One of Us Is Lying,” readers eagerly anticipated the release of its sequel, “One of Us Is Next.” But does it live up to the hype? Let’s delve into a comparison of the two books and highlight both their similarities and differences.

“One of Us Is Lying” “One of Us Is Next”
Plot Takes place in Bayview High where five students walk into detention. Takes place in the same high school and features a new cast of characters being targeted with a dangerous truth-or-dare game.
Writing Style The first book uses multiple perspectives to tell the story. The author employs the same technique in the sequel, but this time with a larger cast of characters.
Tone Darker and more serious with a slower pace… …But still manages to keep readers on their toes with a similar level of suspense and tension.
Themes Explores themes of high school drama, secrets, and social hierarchies. The sequel touches on similar themes but adds the element of facing consequences and taking responsibility for one’s actions.

Overall, “One of Us Is Next” maintains much of the fun and intrigue that made “One of Us Is Lying” so memorable, while still managing to carve out its own unique story. It’s a worthy sequel that fans of the first book will surely enjoy.

Critical Reception

The critical reception of “One of Us Is Next” has been generally positive, with many reviewers praising the book for its suspenseful plot and intriguing characters. However, some have criticized the novel for lacking the surprises and twists that made its predecessor, “One of Us Is Lying,” so captivating.

According to Publishers Weekly, “McManus maintains the tension nicely and offers readers a satisfyingly twisty resolution,” while Kirkus Reviews applauded the author’s “knack for cliffhangers and well-timed reveals.”

On the other hand, The Washington Post claimed that “the story plods along a bit more predictably,” and The New York Times Book Review stated that “unlike McManus’s best twists, this one doesn’t feel earned.”

Despite these divergent opinions, “One of Us Is Next” remains a popular choice among young adult readers and has garnered a strong following since its release. Whether you choose to listen to the audiobook version or read the physical copy, you’re sure to be drawn into the story’s web of mystery, suspense, and danger.

Reader Recommendations

Want to know what readers thought of “One of Us Is Next”? Here are some recommendations and opinions:

  1. “I loved ‘One of Us Is Next’ just as much as the first book! The audiobook was so well done, and I couldn’t stop listening. It’s the perfect mix of suspense, mystery, and drama.” – Sarah K.
  2. “As a fan of Karen M. McManus, I had high expectations for ‘One of Us Is Next,’ and I wasn’t disappointed! The audiobook brought the story to life, and the plot kept me on the edge of my seat until the end.” – Alex G.
  3. “The characters in ‘One of Us Is Next’ are so well-developed, and the narrator did an amazing job of distinguishing their voices. I loved how the plot unfolded, and I was constantly guessing who the culprit could be. Highly recommend the audiobook!” – Lily W.

Overall, readers highly recommend the audiobook version of “One of Us Is Next.” If you’re a fan of thrillers, mysteries, or YA novels, this is a must-listen. Don’t forget to check out our other sections for a comprehensive review of Karen M. McManus’s latest masterpiece!

reader recommendations


“One of Us Is Next” proves to be an exhilarating sequel that lives up to its predecessor. Karen M. McManus once again captivates readers with her intricate plot, well-rounded characters, and masterful narrative. The audiobook version, narrated by Brittany Pressley, delivers a compelling performance that enhances the suspense and tension of the story.

McManus’s writing style and the use of multiple perspectives provide a unique and engaging reading experience that keeps readers hooked from beginning to end. The themes and messages conveyed in the book add depth and substance to the story, elevating it beyond a simple murder mystery.

When compared to “One of Us Is Lying,” “One of Us Is Next” stands out as a worthy sequel that expands upon the original story while remaining true to the essence of the series. The critical reception of the book has been overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers praising McManus’s ability to create a gripping and suspenseful tale.

Overall, “One of Us Is Next” is a must-read (or must-listen) for fans of YA thrillers and murder mysteries. The audiobook version provides an immersive and thrilling experience that will keep you on the edge of your seat until the very end.

Leave a Reply